Tuesday, November 10, 2026

The gist of it - Carbon Dioxide doesn't do it

The cause of climate change is changes in the amount of sunshine reaching the earth's surface.

United Nations Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change(UN IPCC) says:

The earth emits long wave infrared radiation(IR). CO2 absorbs it and re-emits some of it back to the earth making the earth warmer than the sun had made it. They say this is what causes global warming.


That is referred to as the atmospheric greenhouse effect.

What Science says is really simple ...

It is impossible for radiation from CO2 to heat the surface because it is coming from the colder atmosphere and cold cannot heat warm as defined by the 2nd law of thermodynamics, furthermore the radiation that comes from CO2 came from the earth to begin with and no object can be made hotter by its own radiation. Therefore, CO2 does not and cannot cause global warming or climate change. 

This warm period will pass as all the others have done in the past. 

Click image to enlarge
 

See "What happens in Earth's climate system" below for a simple explanation of how the sun effects earth's temperature.

 

Is the radiative greenhouse effect real?

No. Heat is energy transferred because of a temperature difference, and it flows only from hotter to colder. Radiation from cooler atmospheric gases, including CO2, is not heat performed on the warmer surface.

Surface temperature is set by absorbed sunlight, atmospheric mass and pressure, and the gravity-driven lapse. Those already produce the observed profile. A radiative greenhouse is not an extra term in that accounting.
Adiabatic Lapse depiction

 

How does co2 heat the atmosphere?

CO2 does not heat the atmosphere. The atmosphere, including its small CO2 fraction, is heated mainly by conduction and convection from the solar-heated ground and only secondarily by direct absorption of sunlight. Infrared from the warmer ground can be partly absorbed by CO2, but that is ordinary heat flowing from hot to cold and is a tiny contribution compared with contact transfer; the adiabatic lapse already sets the temperature profile without any extra radiative forcing.

Near the surface the relevant vibrational modes of CO2 are already excited by collisions, so the infrared interaction is scattering, not additional heating. Any absorption that could raise the kinetic energy of a CO2 molecule occurs only at high, already-cold altitudes and cannot affect the warmer surface or the bulk of the column. Radiation leaving the atmosphere is a result of its temperature, not a cause of it. Cooler radiation cannot heat a warmer body, heat cannot flow from cold to hot, and a body cannot heat itself with its own radiation; those restrictions follow directly from the first and second laws. CO2 therefore neither traps heat nor produces a radiative greenhouse warming of the air or the surface. 

Co2 does not hold onto the energy from infrared absorption or conduction more than a few microseconds, so would be more like scattering rather than absorption. Its ability to emit energy as infrared radiation makes it an efficient cooler of the atmosphere.

The aforementioned statement by the IPCC has been proven by science to be a lie. It is all part of a globalist campaign of fear to get control of every aspect of the lives of earth's populations. 

How do the multi-atomic atmospheric gases trap heat to keep it from escaping to space?

Multi-atomic gases are CO2(carbon dioxide), CH4(methane), NO2(nitrous oxide), O3(ozone)

They do not. Multi-atomic atmospheric gases cannot trap heat to keep it from escaping to space.

The claimed radiative greenhouse effect does not exist. Radiation from cooler gases cannot heat a warmer surface or act as a barrier that retains energy against the Second Law. Heat is the one-way constitutive transfer from the hotter body to the colder body, Q = sigma (T_h^4 - T_c^4). The surface still emits in full at its own temperature. Most of that infrared is absorbed in cooler air, yet that absorption is an optical fate, not trapping. The cooler gases transfer the remainder of the hot emission through themselves. Heat is not a conserved fluid that can be trapped or inhibited from leaving.

Energy absorbed from the Sun, whether at the surface or in the air, is moved through the column by radiation, convection, conduction and evaporation. It remains in the column until the planet loses energy solely as outgoing longwave radiation. Vacuum accepts no heat by contact, so conduction and convection never leak energy off the planet. 

A physical greenhouse traps heated air by blocking convection. The open atmosphere does the opposite: it flows and cools heated objects, enhancing surface cooling rather than retarding it. The atmosphere holds heat because it has mass and temperature; that is not trapping.

Surface temperature is set by solar input, atmospheric mass and pressure, and the gravity-driven lapse rate from the First Law. Extra multi-atomic gases cannot reopen that accounting.

How is most of the energy removed from the surface of the earth?

Most of the energy is removed from the Earth's surface by conduction and convection into the cooler air immediately above it, together with evaporation. Those contact processes dominate because the gravity-driven lapse already places the near-surface air at nearly the same temperature as the ground. 

The surface obeys the First Law dE_s = H - C = m Cp dT_s. H is heat performed on the surface and exists only from a hotter source (absorbed sunlight, which is zero at night). C is every leaving mode, each driven by the contrast with the adjacent air whose temperature T_δ is already set by contact and the adiabat: C_conv of order k(T_s - T_δ), C_diff of order b(T_s - T_δ), C_evap, and C_rad of order sigma(T_s^4 - T_δ^4). When the surface is warmer, every term cools the ground. The atmosphere constantly cools the surface. The radiative difference is small; the surface still emits its full spontaneous flux sigma T_s^4, most of which is absorbed in cooler air rather than travelling to space. That energy remains in the column until the planet loses it as outgoing longwave.

The so called "greenhouse" gases, the radiatively active gases, CO2(carbon dioxide), CH4(methane), NO2(nitrous oxide), O3(ozone), misnamed "greenhouse gases" because they do not hold onto energy nor do they prevent it from leaving the atmosphere, will within a few micro-seconds lose that energy in collision with other molecules or by radiating that energy at the speed of light in the form of infrared at frequencies governed by their temperature. Those gases do not act as the glass walls and ceiling of a green house that work by blocking convection which traps warmed air. There is no atmospheric greenhouse effect. 
For more depth, read: https://climateofsophistry.com/2024/09/10/despite-recent-results-there-is-still-no-greenhouse-effect-fourier-was-right/

What those special trace gases, that are less than 0.05% of the atmosphere, do is to help cool the earth because of their ability to emit radiation. They do not heat the atmosphere. Radiation is the only way for earth to lose heat gained from the sun and it happens 24/7 continuously. The surface emits, the atmosphere emits, clouds emit, water vapor emits, CO₂ emits, ozone emits, and under the appropriate conditions even species often treated as “radiatively inactive” can participate through more sporadic/intermittent or regime-dependent processes. Everything above absolute zero emits radiation.  Don’t think of Outgoing Longwave Radiation(OLR) as coming from a single gas or a single layer of the Earth-atmosphere system. Think of it as the sum of all radiative processes occurring throughout the Earth-atmosphere system

That emission comes from the atmosphere as a whole at the temperatures set by the gravity-driven lapse. It is not a special action of particular multi-atomic gases. Most surface infrared is absorbed in cooler air and never leaves the planet. Energy absorbed from the Sun, whether at the ground or in the air, is moved through the column by radiation, convection, conduction and evaporation until the planet loses energy solely as this outgoing longwave. Vacuum accepts no heat by contact, so the only energy leaving is that longwave. Radiation from cooler atmospheric gases, so called "backradiation", is not heat performed on the warmer surface and cannot raise its temperature.

2025 ended with a steadily declining rate of rising CO2 in the atmosphere following a 20 month cooling since April 2024, peak of an unusual and unexplained warming spike.  That rate declined further in the first four months of 2026. Historical records show that around 1875 was the coldest time in the last 10,000 years.  That was the end of the Little Ice Age (LIA), and since then temperatures have warmed at an average rate of about 0.5C per century.  The recovery of the biosphere and ocean warming resulted in rising levels of CO2 in the atmosphere. -- Ron Clutz
https://rclutz.com/2026/05/20/april-2026-cooling-temperatures-lead-to-co2-rate-decline/

Carbon Dioxide vs Air in heated bottles does not prove "Greenhouse" effect

This is an experiment performed in college classrooms said to prove the greenhouse effect. Two bottles of equal capacity are heated from the same heat source and the temperatures of the gases are measured. The bottle of CO2 will be hotter than the bottle of ambient air. Why? Because ...

Heat capaciy C, kilojoules kJ, kilograms*Kelvin kgK:

Note: Kelvin is absolute temperature starting at 0; i.e. no molecular movement. Earths temperature at the surface is about 288K.

C = kJ/kgK
Air C=1.007
CO2 C=.8459

Air has 19% greater heat capacity than CO2.

The same amount of thermal energy will cause CO2 to attain a higher temperature than an equal amount of air because air has 19% more heat capacity than CO2.

Co2 requires less energy to achieve the same temperature as air due to its lower heat capacity so it will get hotter than the air when equal amounts of each are heated with the same amount of energy. This is not how the greenhouse effect works. They are different phenomena. They have nothing to do with each other. Hotter CO2 in a bottle does not prove the greenhouse effect. It just proves that CO2 has lower heat capacity. 

Most of the added heat energy goes directly into increasing the kinetic energy of the gas molecule that has a lower specific heat capacity increasing its temperature.

Added heat is absorbed into internal processes of a gas with higher heat capacity rather than increasing its kinetic energy or temperature.

The same amount of thermal energy will cause CO2 to attain a higher temperature than an equal amount of air because air has 19% more heat capacity than CO2.
 

What's wrong with the "greenhouse" effect as described by the U.N. IPCC
https://climateofsophistry.com/2016/02/26/slayer-double-victory/

Thermodynamic Climate Interpreter
Ask any question about radiation, thermodynamics, atmospheric physics, the greenhouse effect, CO₂, climate models, or energy balance. All answers are sourced exclusively from accepted thermodynamic and mathematical principles.
https://climate-thermo-interpreter.vercel.app/ 
By: Joseph E Postma - https://climateofsophistry.com/2026/08/16/postmas-thermodynamic-climate-interpreter/

Carbon Dioxide is a bit player in a sea of Nitrogen and Oxygen.
Nitrogen and Oxygen both absorb thermal energy(heat) from the sunlight heated surface via conduction due to intimate contact with that surface and then as all matter does, radiate that energy in infrared frequencies based on its temperature in all directions and some back to the surface, although re-radiation to the surface does not heat the surface as stated above. Nitrogen and Oxygen make up 99.3% of the atmosphere swamping the effect of Carbon Dioxide which is only 0.04%.
https://www.americanthinker.com/articles/2010/02/the_hidden_flaw_in_greenhouse.html 

Tom Harris lays out the truth of the climate alarmist efforts and the climate.
The Climate Lie: Scientist Blows Open UN Fraud, Global Censorship, and China’s Power Grab at COP30 in Brazil (Exclusive Interview)
Very enlightening video, worth the 45 minute view.

https://rumble.com/v72dcge-tom-harris-on-brazil-cop-30-climate-conference-nov-28-2025.html 

Life on earth developed many millions of years ago with 10 to 15 times, maybe more, the amount of CO2 in the atmosphere that there is today. Why would anyone think that today's amount is dangerous to life? That is illogical. Research has shown that dropping CO2 concentration to 150 ppm is a death knell for plants. Removal of CO2 from the atmosphere is the path to extinction of all life on earth. On the other hand, with multiple thousands of ppm life thrives on earth.

If CO2 was the driver of global warming we should have been cooked many years ago when CO2 was several thousand parts per million. We are being scammed.

 

Temperature Changes Cause CO2 Changes, Not the Reverse
"Changes in CO2 follow changes in global temperatures on all time scales, from last month’s observations to ice core datasets spanning millennia. Since CO2 is the lagging variable, it cannot logically be the cause of temperature, the leading variable. It is folly to imagine that by reducing human emissions of CO2, we can change global temperatures, which are obviously driven by other factors.
More CO2 actually benefits the world. It is not a pollutant at all, and we should have the courage to do nothing about CO2 emissions" --Dr. William Happer 2025
https://rclutz.com/2025/09/18/ml-co2-follows-temperatures-from-hadcrut5/

Sources and sinks for CO2 are many. However, changes in atmospheric CO2 follow changes in global air temperature, and changes in global air temperature follow changes in ocean surface temperature. #5 on home page.
https://www.climate4you.com/

Temperature change leads change in CO2
 

CO2 keeps rising even though air temperature doesn't. As the oceans warm they start emitting CO2 and because they take a long time to cool, they keep releasing CO2 even after the atmosphere cools. We've known this for a long time, but you don't make any money saying that there is no problem with CO2. See the direct link to Murry Salby's video below the following graphs.
https://hockeyschtick.blogspot.com/2013/06/climate-scientist-dr-murry-salby.html

Climate models have been falsified by observations over the past 2 decades.

 

 The following chart of proxy temperatures and CO2 during the Eemian warm period, the last interglacial before the current one, shows how CO2 levels stayed up after cooling began.


 Murry L. Salby is a climate scientist. He points out the fallacy of the global warming pseudo-science of the United Nations Inter-governmental Panel on Climate Change (UN IPCC) in his lecture of October 2018 given at Helmut Schmidt University
in Hamburg, Germany, with math. CO2 levels in the atmosphere are in response to temperature changes. CO2 is not responsible for temperature changes. 
Human emissions of CO2 as a percentage of total CO2 have been greatly exaggerated. The record of total CO2 does not reflect the supposed rise in anthropogenic CO2.
(This lecture is 1.5 hrs long, but worth the view. You can jump ahead by clicking in the time bar at the bottom.)

https://climatecite.com/murry-salby-atmospheric-science/ 

Reduced cloud cover since about 1980 is responsible for ALL of the warming of the last 45 years. Not human emissions of carbon dioxide.
Ned Nikolov, Ph.D.
@NikolovScience
Published 2024

From section 3. Results:
"atmospheric longwave radiation is simply a manifestation of the ambient thermal energy already present in the climate system rather than an external source of heat as assumed by the greenhouse theory. Hence, the downwelling atmospheric LW flux does not contribute to the planet’s GSAT [Global Surface Air Temperature].
This implies that a global longwave radiative forcing predicted by climate models and attributed to rising concentrations of atmospheric trace gases does not exist in reality. According to this new physical framework, the global climate can only change if either the mean atmospheric surface pressure is significantly altered or the amount of sunlight absorbed by the planet is modified, mainly through modulation of the cloud albedo (assuming, of course, there is no change in the planet’s mean annual distance from the Sun). The albedo mechanism of climate change is robustly demonstrated by the CERES measurements."
Study: https://mdpi.com/2673-7418/4/3/17
Comment by Nikolov: https://climateofsophistry.com/2025/08/02/the-history-of-climate-sophistry/#comment-131103


Empirical evidence proves carbon dioxide(CO2) does not control earths' temperature:
Historical CO2 levels are reported as being about 280 parts per million(ppm) for about 20 million years prior to 1850. With CO2 levels fairly constant, the Medieval Warm Period occurred from year 1000AD to 1300AD with temperatures a few degrees warmer than our current  15°C(59°F) then the Little Ice age from about 1400AD to 1800AD saw temperatures a few degrees cooler than 15°C. Those temperature swings occurred without notable changes in CO2 levels. Clearly, there is another driver of temperature.
https://climateofsophistry.com/2025/08/02/the-history-of-climate-sophistry/#comment-131323


Climate change correlates with solar output

 Some conclusions from research:
Human CO₂ ≈ 4% of the carbon flux(the amount that goes in an out of the atmosphere)
Models fail vs. observations
Cloud cover ≫ CO₂ in radiative impact
Solar cycles correlate better with climate
Physical spectroscopy disproves strong CO₂ forcing
So, no—the CO₂ you exhale, burn, or emit does not cause dangerous global warming. The Earth’s climate responds to cosmic-scale natural forces, not to the exhaust pipes of civilization. 

 

The obvious question:  is the underlying principle of the atmospheric greenhouse effect, as stated by the IPCC above, actually defined, anywhere?

All I have to tell you, is that “No, it is not.”
https://climateofsophistry.com/2013/01/25/sophistry-part-2-analogously-but-different-or-why-the-ipcc-lies-or-how-the-ipcc-disproves-the-greenhouse-effect/


Clouds are the earth's thermostat... 
Very simply, when the earth heats up, more clouds are formed and clouds block sunshine. That causes cooling. When the earth is cooler, fewer clouds are formed letting more sunshine reach the surface warming the earth. The following 3 articles explain more.
https://jennifermarohasy.com/2026/10/new-theory-of-climate-resilience-plank-1-summary-and-example
https://climatecite.com/the-cloud-thermostat-is-the-dominant-climate-controlling-mechanism/ Very Long
https://wattsupwiththat.com/2009/06/14/the-thermostat-hypothesis/ 

 

The following short video makes strong points in short segments. It gives a rundown of facts on global warming.
https://rumble.com/v7do5e2-the-climate-change-narrative-part-2.html?e9s=src_v1_s%2Csrc_v1_s_o&sci=5ad983dd-bc07-4a79-a6b1-fc0c852bfe92
 

The Heat Under Your Feet Is An Unaccounted For Input To Global Warming

Heat from earth's core rises up to the crust and heats the deep ocean and land which heats the atmosphere. Over 2 decades of research went into this article.

https://theethicalskeptic.com/2020/02/16/the-climate-change-alternative-we-ignore-to-our-peril/

See https://www.ourwoods.org/ for more essays and articles.

 

The gist of it - Carbon Dioxide doesn't do it

The cause of climate change is changes in the amount of sunshine reaching the earth's surface. United Nations Intergovernmental Panel on...