Clouds block sunlight and cause cooling.
Cloudless skies let more sunshine get to the surface and cause warming.
Clouds have a great effect on temperature. Carbon dioxide has NO measurable effect.
Earth's cooling system keeps it from overheating by directly radiating excess energy to space from the tops of tropical thunderstorms. More heat from the sun means more is radiated to space. We are not in danger of overheating.
https://jennifermarohasy.com/2026/10/new-theory-of-climate-resilience-plank-1-summary-and-example
It is impossible for radiation from CO2 to heat the surface because that radiation is coming from the colder atmosphere and cold cannot heat warm as defined by the 2nd law of thermodynamics and therefore CO2 cannot cause global warming or climate change.
The sun heats the surface and the surface heats the air via conduction and convection because the surface and the air are in intimate contact.
The surface is generally warmer than the air, so the air cannot heat the surface. The earth also radiates some infrared energy that is mostly absorbed by water which carries it from the surface by convection and releases that energy as sensible heat high up in the atmosphere during the condensation process that forms clouds. That warmed air is then mixed with the stratosphere by air currents where it is radiated to space. Water is the coolant in Earth's natural air conditioner. Although, as mentioned earlier, Nitrogen and Oxygen overwhelm the cooling effect of both Carbon Dioxide and water. Carbon Dioxide(CO2) does nothing much at all in the troposphere except help move energy from the surface up to the tropopause as do all other gases in the atmosphere. Radiation to space of the energy from the earth is a continuum from the surface and all levels of the atmosphere and all gases, not just one level or gas.
The radiation active gases, CO2(carbon dioxide), CH4(methane), NO2(nitrous oxide), O3(ozone), are misnamed "greenhouse gases". Those misnamed gases do not act like the walls and ceiling of a greenhouse trapping heat or radiation in the atmosphere.
Earth's surface acts as a thermal battery storing energy from the sun and releases it slowly day and night 24/7. In summer there is more solar energy reaching the ground. This is why the atmosphere gets warmer in the summer. The opposite happens in winter with the surface cooling and thus not heating the atmosphere as much. To understand the real source of heating of the atmosphere, think about the real climate-change that happens every year.
Due to the 23.5 degree tilt of Earth's axis, after December 21st the northern hemisphere starts to get more exposure to sunshine and the north starts to warm after a lag of about 30 or 40 days with more sunshine reaching the surface. The opposite happens on June 21st and the northern hemisphere starts to cool down after a lag of about 30 or 40 days with less exposure to sunshine. At 38° north latitude, where I live, due to the tilt of the Earth's axis there is about half as much sunshine at about 464 watts/sqr meter for 9-1/2 hours on December 21st as there is on June 21st at about 926 watts/sqr meter for 14-1/2 hours. That's an extra 5 hours exposure to double the sunshine power in June over December. According to https://dqydj.com/solar-irradiance-calculator/, that amounts to 3.25 times the solar energy at the zenith in June over December. This creates a huge climate change every year with about 50 degrees Fahrenheit difference between January(37°F avg) and July(87°F avg). Nobody screams about that climate change which is all due to the amount of exposure to sun light. Why are we worried about 1.5°F change over the last 175 years and there is a BIG question about the accuracy of those temperature records?
Temperatures have cycled up and down for as far back as has been researched. 1000 years ago temperatures were several degrees warmer than they are today, known as the Medieval Warm Period, afterwards the earth dropped into a cold period know as the Little Ice Age. Carbon dioxide had nothing to do with creating the Medieval Warm Period or the Little Ice Age that followed. Current warming is simply the cycle coming out of the previous cold period. A matching cycle, discovered by John Eddy, is about 950 years long and matches up with past warm and cold periods. It has been going on for many thousands of years. This is just one of many cycles, solar and planetary, that have an effect on earth's climate.
See https://www.almanac.com/what-are-solar-cycles-and-how-do-they-affect-weather
And https://andymaypetrophysicist.com/2016/09/27/solar-variability-and-the-earths-climate/.

The radiative theory that CO2 drives climate (global warming) falls over by the fact that the air at 35 degrees south latitude between 600hPa and 200 hPa in the southern hemisphere is warmer in winter than it is in summer.
ReplyDeleteThe heating of the atmosphere is due primarily to contact with warm surfaces, chiefly the skin of landmasses and by the excitation of CO2 and ozone by outgoing long wave radiation ( ie. air doesn't heat the land or ocean). The gases excited by long wave radiation pass on energy instantaneously to adjacent molecules a process dependent on atmospheric density (so fastest at the surface ) which then accelerates convection.
As the air rises it cools via decompression, not so much radiation. Necessarily, an equivalent volume of cooler denser air descends in the winter hemisphere over cold continents and the oceans. As the air descends it is compressed and warms, driving enhanced long wave radiation that escapes with greatest ease where the atmosphere is less dense, less humid and less cloudy. The air density at about 5 km in elevation is already half of that at the surface. It’s a fact that the air at 35 degrees south latitude between 600hPa and 200 hPa in the southern hemisphere is warmer in winter than it is in summer. That’s due to enhanced descent and compression in winter, and a small increase in ozone content.
The Earth as a whole is appreciably warmer at the time of northern hemisphere summer when the continental landmasses heat the atmosphere. This reduces cloud cover allowing more solar radiation to reach the surface. In June and July, solar radiation is 6% weaker than in January because the sun is more distant at that time. So, it’s the cloud that really matters.
Long term weather cycles define climate.
https://reality348.wordpress.com/
The so called climate catastrophe is just a fairy tale. The atmosphere is primarily incapable of accumulating energy. It is less than skin deep given 90% of its mass is within 10km of the surface and the bulk of that is at a temperature well below the freezing point of water.
Clouds modulate the amount of sunlight that falls on the ocean which absorbs shortwave energy to depth. Average surface temperature across the globe is 15C. Optimum surface temperature for photosynthesis is 25-30C.
The Earth is closest to the sun in January and solar radiation is 6% more intense at that time. The two warmest Januarys for the Southern Hemisphere occurred in 1983 (17.9 ) and 2025 (18.1), a difference of less than 0.2C. - which is imperceptible, a rounding error, a difference that one would have little confidence in asserting is real because of the difficulty in measuring temperature over such an area. The coolest years, being 1948 (17.1) and 1999 (17.2), have a difference of only 0.1degrees C. The difference between coolest and warmest January is 1 degree C. So the absolute range between coolest and warmest Januarys is about five times that between the difference between the two warmest years. The conclusion: This is well within the range of natural variation. Secondly: don't be conned by people with an agenda whose impartiality and judgement cannot be trusted.
Data from https://psl.noaa.gov/cgi-bin/data/timeseries/timeseries.pl?ntype=1&var=Air+Temperature&level=1000&lat1=0&lat2=-90&lon1=0&lon2=360&iseas=1&mon1=0&mon2=0&iarea=1&typeout=1&Submit=Create+Timeseries
more here.
https://open.substack.com/pub/tucoschild/p/draft-co-cannot-warm-the-earth?utm_source=share&utm_medium=android&r=17bedn
Good stuff.
ReplyDelete